33 Comments
User's avatar
TestPilot's avatar

Look a little closer, and you’ll find that there was, in fact, only one MeToo movement.

The point was to abrogate due process for the enemies of the movement, and to reduce the burden of proof for claims made by members of said movement.

The idea that this was “necessary” is based on hysterical, specious arguments, which “just be a good person” libs were cowed into accepting.

E.g., the claims that Western society has always been deeply unfair to women, that women were routinely assumed to be liars by law enforcement prior to 2015 (except for when the accusations were leveled against non-whites, apparently, in which case women were always believed), and that sweeping changes to law and culture were necessary to remedy this.

Not surprisingly, these revelations came to light around the same time that women started to outnumber men in the workplace, the media, and the academy. Wow. Crazy coincidence.

As a result, we got “believe all women,” the elimination of statutes of limitations for crimes most likely to affect women, contemporaneous hearsay re-categorized as viable evidence (E Jean Carrol, Blasey-Ford), and, my favorite, the phrase “credibly accused of sexual misconduct/assault” introduced into the public lexicon.

That last one is really something: you’re presumed guilty if a woman that the press finds credible says you’re guilty. The ladies are judges and lawyers in large numbers now, so 800 years of Anglo jurisprudential tradition are just gonna have to take a backseat. “You’re not a bigot, are you? A misogynist?”

None of this was in any way necessary. Not to prosecute Mean Bad Harvey, nor to prosecute anyone else who’d broken the law. The pre-2015 standards of evidence were sufficient. Neither trial-by-press, nor trial-by-HR, nor trial-by-Title IX Office have delivered a more just society. Quite the opposite.

It was, however, necessary for giving angry women and envious/weak men the power to oust their male competitors from positions they’d prefer to have for themselves or their friends, and for enabling petty, vengeful people to extract punishment for the high crime of failing to be sufficiently deferential.

All of the due-process destroying innovations of the MeToo era should be reversed, tomorrow. The people responsible for implementing them belong in a gulag—though I’d settle for a Waffle House kitchen.

Do not be a coward. Do not bow and scrape before the people who demand that you say MeToo was “necessary.” There is no fair, happy mid-point they will allow you to negotiate. They will always come back for more, and the truth means nothing to them.

Karen Arnold's avatar

Well said!

Patricia J.'s avatar

"elimination of statutes of limitations"

This led, for one other thing, to a $4 billion settlement with thousands of plaintiffs who claim they were abused in the L.A. County juvenile system. Now the county is investigating fraud in some of those claims, but it's a mess and would bankrupt the county if it stays.

Chris Nathan's avatar

This article is persuasive. It makes falsifiable claims. It employs logic. It takes into account and addresses plausible alternative hypotheses. It considers the mindset of the protagonists without making excessive claims about other people’s mental states. It’s almost old-fashioned in this sense. It’s striking how unusual that is these days.

Adrian Blake's avatar

Very well said. The last decade revealed a form of ideological mania that swept through Western society, premised on the idea that emotional justice supersedes the logic-based, evidentiary systems that have anchored Western civilization since the Enlightenment. The reduction of complex human life into a childish binary of "good guys and bad guys"—defined almost entirely by group identity—was intellectually bankrupt, yet it drilled deep into our institutions. Why? Because it was remarkably effective.

As a mechanism for neutralizing rivals and seizing power, few forces have matched the institutional capture driven by these sacred causes. From university presidencies and corporate boardrooms to elected offices and Hollywood greenlights, this ideological skeleton key worked everywhere—and its beneficiaries are deeply reluctant to relinquish it.

Worse than merely rewarding virtue-signaling, it empowered the weak and the unscrupulous. It allowed individuals who lacked the merit to earn distinction on their own to snatch it from others. Ultimately, it permitted people who have never taken a genuine risk in their lives to brand themselves "brave and transgressive" for doing nothing more than echoing the fashionable consensus of the day. It was a collective abandonment of intellectual rigor in favor of our baser impulses: envy, careerism, and self-indulgence.

Do I want a society that is genuinely fair to women and minorities? As a father of daughters—one of whom is mixed-race—of course I do. But secular religious mania is not how we build it. You cannot construct a just world by burning down the very foundations of truth, merit, and evidence.

Chris Coffman's avatar

You’re not disgraced, Roy—shake it off and continue to fight the good fight. The best may well be still ahead!

Tom Concannon's avatar

There is a much simpler, universal lesson that will be drawn from these times, (2016 until it actually ends). It’s a lesson that has many thousands of years of human history supporting it and today it needs to be relearned 95% by the left and maybe 5% by those that identify conservative. The lesson: Don’t Lie! It’s a rule in every human religion predating Progressivism or Apocalyptic Environmentalism or Radical Feminism. When you lie you are always on “The wrong side”, of History, of Morality, of Justice, of Anything. It’s that simple.

Jared A. Brock's avatar

The real question is: Why haven't you sued her for costing you literally tens of millions, and sued Amazon for wrongful dismissal? At the very least, you'd get to see what's in their files.

Roy Price's avatar

Well, I settled with Amazon but why I didn’t sue the others is a good question. In California, there isn’t really a right to sue someone for libel. Technically there is, on the books, but no one has won a libel case for years because of “anti-SLAPP” laws which were created to pander to and protect publishing companies. The Hulk Hogan case against Gawker was invasion of privacy.

Tim Lorge's avatar

To quote Balckstone’s ratio via Ben Franklin, “It is better 100 guilty persons should escape than that one innocent person should suffer.”

ClBart's avatar

How does anyone get away with lying about and destroying someone else when all the facts point in the other direction?

Patricia J.'s avatar

Moral panic. And then eventually the truth will out.

TimesUp began to lose steam when its leader had to resign after revelations she was helping Gov. Cuomo slime the women who accused him. So, not all that noble at all.

John's avatar

I think they had it out for you, but what do I know? 🤷‍♂️

Stephanie A's avatar

The idea that some group of humans is pure and above self-interest is patently false.

Malignant narcissists grasping power is the only reason such a ridiculous premise will be forced on us.

john andrews's avatar

Thank you so much for this account. I always saw you as a serious, thoughtful exec. All I ever thought from what I read of that incident was that there was a little loose talk in the context of some industry partying during an Uber ride that was misinterpreted as a come-on and it had been blown up and used against you. You certainly were never thought of as crude or misogynistic in the years that preceded. Best Wishes!

Ben Slivka's avatar

Who were the cowards at AMZN who would not stand up for you, especially given the earlier thorough investigation? I had a much milder -- and not economically harmful -- experience in late 2002: https://hxstem.substack.com/p/northwestern-cancels-former-trustee -- zero due process. None of the 40 trustees I knew well had any courage to stand up and defend my absurdly unfair treatment. Which made me grok Bulgakov's statement that "Cowardice is the most terrible of vices" (The Master and Margarita).

Roy Price's avatar

That week was extremely fraught and, as a retailer, Amazon has to be sensitive to public opinion — right or wrong. So … the easiest thing to do by far was to go with the flow.

As an employee, you’re always the lizard’s tail…

Ben Slivka's avatar

Sigh. No moral compass. You lasted longer than me: I arrived in 9/1999, was given half the engineers in 1/2000, and left in 6/2000. Because Bezos was making too many mistakes that made my job impossible. Obviously Amazon survived my departure. :-)

Cody Knotts's avatar

The absurdity of claiming all allegations are true was self evident. But mosr are cowards hoping they can survive rather than we gobbled up. Worse, few can let go and admit they were wrong. All of this happens because our world is too safe and we went far too long in the cocoon of safety. Similar sociological situation happen in late 19th century with fainting couches. It ended with men having real injuries from the First World War. We have compounded the problems with the use of social media and lack enforcement of libel laws. Public figures have almost no recourse to slander. Its a standard from NY vs Sullivan that should be weakened for non political public figures. I will pray that you will be vidcated and the truth will be transparent.

William J. Hawkins's avatar

Roy, I can only imagine how painful it was for you to be victimized by these immoral people and the cowards at Amazon.

I admire you for fighting back. Your side of the story could not be more persuasive.

Just so you know, when the charges against you became public, there was a lot of skepticism.

I remember having a conversation about this matter with one of the most intelligent professionals I have ever known -- who happens to be a female screenwriter. She was quick to doubt the charges against you for several reasons.

We continue to believe you are the #1 thought leader in the American film business.

Kelli Bixler's avatar

In my humble opinion, yellow journalism has always existed, but it feels far more pervasive in today’s endless 24/7 stream of information. Somewhere along the way, we’ve become less concerned with facts, less willing to weigh truth carefully—and that erosion affects our humanity. Humanity deserves higher standards, accountability, and principles. Journalism’s role is to report the facts of humanity: “meticulously sourced, verified,” and free from sensationalism.

In more than 35 years in the entertainment industry, Roy Price was the only studio head who consistently returned my calls within 24 hours and attended award shows for animated preschool series—something virtually unheard of in Hollywood. Roy championed children’s entertainment rather than treating it as a second-class corner of the industry. He supported our creative work, as did the talented executives he hired, and his absence left the children’s entertainment world with one less advocate for meaningful programming for kids. I think that’s disgraceful.

It is my sincere hope that Amazon’s new leadership recognizes the value of children’s entertainment—socially, morally, and economically—and fully commits to the kid’s business once again. Thank you Roy!

Sean Hood's avatar

I’m glad to have read your side of this story. I remember once seeing your face next to Harvey Weinstein’s in a newspaper article and thinking how “disgrace” had lobbed you into a bin in which you clearly (even if Isa’s account had been accurate) didn’t belong. There was no account in any of the articles I read of your side of the events at all, and I can’t imagine that you hadn’t provided it.

Roy Price's avatar

Thanks for reading. They don’t ask for comment when they do these articles. Or they didn’t ask me anyway.